Is Custrd or Yummly the better recipe app?

Yummly indexes more of the open web. Custrd hosts what it returns — photo, steps, macros, no click-out. Choose based on whether you want breadth or a page you can cook from.

When should I pick Custrd over Yummly?

You've been burned by Yummly recipes that click out to SEO content with missing steps, and you want the recipe on the page you are already on.

When should I pick Yummly over Custrd?

You enjoy bouncing across millions of recipes from thousands of food blogs and don't mind the variable quality.

Is Custrd free to use?

The Custrd web recipe finder at custrd.com/recipe-finder is free with no signup. The iOS app starts with a 7-day free trial of Custrd Pro, then $39.99/year ($3.33/mo) — or $9.99/month with no trial. Cancel anytime in Settings > Apple ID > Subscriptions.

Comparison · Updated 2026-05-27

Custrd vs. Yummly

A 200,000-recipe library you can search by ingredient vs. an aggregated open-web index

Feature-by-feature comparison

Feature	Custrd	Yummly
Recipe hosted on the platform, photo and all	No click-out	Aggregated from open web
Recipe count	200,000+	Millions
Recipe served on platform (no click-out)		Click out to source
Match recipes to ingredients you have
Photograph fridge for ingredients	iOS app
Fit percentage per match
Free web tool with no signup		Limited without account
Smart oven integration		Whirlpool ecosystem
Macro / nutrition per recipe
Ad-free recipe pages		Ad-supported

The honest summary

Yummly's strength is volume — millions of recipes aggregated from across the web. Its weakness is the same: open-web quality is uneven.

Every recipe Custrd returns has a real hero image, normalized ingredients and complete steps — no click-out to find out what is missing.

Yummly recipes click out to the original blog with its ads and pop-ups. Custrd recipes are served on a clean page with no interstitial.

Common questions

Is Custrd or Yummly the better recipe app?: Yummly indexes more of the open web. Custrd hosts what it returns — photo, steps, macros, no click-out. Choose based on whether you want breadth or a page you can cook from.
When should I pick Custrd over Yummly?: You've been burned by Yummly recipes that click out to SEO content with missing steps, and you want the recipe on the page you are already on.
When should I pick Yummly over Custrd?: You enjoy bouncing across millions of recipes from thousands of food blogs and don't mind the variable quality.
Is Custrd free to use?: The Custrd web recipe finder is free with no signup. The iOS app starts with a 7-day free trial of Custrd Pro, then $39.99/year ($3.33/mo) — or $9.99/month with no trial. Cancel anytime in Settings > Apple ID > Subscriptions.